Cold-process soap · formula OC-01

Oat & Cedar Bar

A palm-free, vegan everyday bar built from five oils. Six of SoapCalc's seven quality numbers land within about a point of the middle of their suggested ranges. Bubbly runs low, the price of keeping the bar gentle, and sugar and castor make up for it. Every additive is used at a rate taken from a named source.

5%superfat
33%lye concentration
NaOHbar soap lye
7.3%linoleic + linolenic
6 wkcure before sale

Batch sheet

Type your oil weight and every line rescales. Weigh everything; never measure soap ingredients by volume.

Ingredient% of oilsWeightWhen

The numbers

These are computed on this page from SoapCalc's own fatty-acid table for each oil, weighted by the oil percentages. The shaded band is SoapCalc's suggested range; the thin tick is its midpoint; the purple mark is this bar.

SoapCalc suggested rangemidpointOat & Cedar

SoapCalc calls these ranges guidelines, and experienced makers on the Soapmaking Forum point out the numbers don't capture everything (feel, cure, water). Treat them as a check that nothing is out of balance, then judge the real bar.

Why each ingredient, at that amount

Olive oil

40% of oils

The mild, conditioning base. SoapCalc lists olive at 69% oleic acid and no lauric, so it adds conditioning without adding harshness. At 40% it's the largest share without turning the bar into a soft, slow-curing castile.

Buy regular or refined olive oil, not pomace. SoapCalc lists "Olive Oil pomace" as a separate oil with its own values, and these numbers were computed for regular olive oil.

Data: SoapCalc oil chart

Coconut oil, 76°

24% of oils

Lather and cleaning power, from 48% lauric and 19% myristic acid. Those two acids are SoapCalc's Cleansing number. At 24% the bar scores 16.1 on a 12–22 range: just under the midpoint, so it lathers and cleans without the tight feel of high-coconut bars.

Tested alternatives: at 22% coconut, hardness fell to 39.8 and bubbly to 21.0. At 24%, hardness is 41.0 and bubbly 22.4, with Cleansing still under 17. Each extra point of coconut adds about 0.67 to Cleansing.

Data: SoapCalc oil chart; formulas: Classic Bells, SoapCalc numbers

Shea butter, refined

15% of oils

Hardness and a dense, creamy lather from 40% stearic acid. Bramble Berry recommends 15% or less in cold process and notes that shea adds hardness and conditioning but not lather, which is why coconut and castor carry the bubbles.

Refined shea is more consistent batch to batch. SAP values for shea vary by grade: The Soapery lists 0.133 refined and 0.129 organic, and SoapCalc uses 0.128. This sheet uses SoapCalc's 0.128. If yours is really 0.133, the superfat moves from 5.0% to about 5.5%, which is harmless.

Bramble Berry, All About Butters; The Soapery SAP chart

Cocoa butter, deodorized

14% of oils

This replaces palm oil. Palm's job in soap is palmitic and stearic acid, which make a hard, long-lasting bar. Cocoa butter is 28% palmitic and 33% stearic. Bramble Berry and Soap Queen both cap it around 15% because more can crack the bars, so 14% leaves a margin.

Deodorized, because natural cocoa butter smells of chocolate and would fight the lavender and cedar.

Bramble Berry, All About Butters

Castor oil

7% of oils

The lather booster. Castor is about 90% ricinoleic acid, the only common soap oil with much of it, and ricinoleic counts toward Bubbly, Creamy and Conditioning at once. SoapCalc says most recipes use 5–8% and above 10% the bar gets sticky; 7% is inside that window.

SoapCalc oil chart notes; Classic Bells

Sodium hydroxide at 5% superfat

≈13.8% of oils

The lye is calculated from SoapCalc's NaOH SAP values, then reduced 5% so a little oil stays unsaponified. The 5% isn't arbitrary. Reputable SAP tables disagree by up to 0.005 g/g for the same oil (SoapCalc against From Nature With Love). If every oil in this bar were really 0.005 lower than the value used here, the effective superfat would still be 1.6%: no free lye.

A higher superfat would leave more free oil in the bar, which is softer and has more to oxidize.

SoapCalc oil chart; FNWL saponification chart

Water at 33% lye concentration

≈28% of oils

About 2 parts water to 1 part lye. That's a moderate water discount, and the same concentration Lovely Greens uses for its oatmeal soap. Less water gives a firmer bar at cutting and a faster cure. 30 g per kg of oils is held back to dissolve the sugar and EDTA, so the lye solution itself runs at about 36%, well inside the safe range for NaOH.

Lovely Greens, Oatmeal Soap; Making Soap Naturally, cure guide

Sodium lactate, 60% liquid

1% of oils

Makes the bar harden faster and release cleanly from the mold, which matters in a palm-free bar. Bramble Berry's rate is 1 tsp per pound of oils; Nurture puts that at about 1–3% of oil weight and warns that too much makes a hard, crumbly bar. Cocoa butter and shea already provide hardness, so this uses the low end. Add it to the lye solution once it has cooled below about 130°F.

Bramble Berry, All About Sodium Lactate; Nurture Soap

Sugar

1% of oils

Boosts bubbles to make up for this bar's modest Bubbly score (22 on a 14–46 range). The common rate is about 1 teaspoon per pound of oils, which is close to 1% by weight. Countryside warns that sugar scorches and darkens in hot lye, so it goes in the separate reserved water instead.

Countryside, Salt, Sugar and Sodium Lactate in Soap

Colloidal oatmeal

1.4% of oils

Lovely Greens uses 1 Tbsp (6.5 g) of oats per 454 g of oils and recommends no more than that. That's 1.4%, well under Bramble Berry's limit of 5% of the soap's total weight. Colloidal oatmeal is milled fine enough to disperse evenly; Lovely Greens notes that quick oats stirred into lye can thicken into a paste, so here it's mixed into a little of the olive oil and added at thin trace.

Its job here is feel, appearance and the name on the label. This bar makes no skin-relief claims for it (see Selling it).

Lovely Greens, Oatmeal Soap; Bramble Berry, Colloidal Oatmeal

Tetrasodium EDTA

0.1% of oils

A chelator that ties up trace metals. Classic Bells calls metal contamination the most important trigger for rancidity in soap and says that, given one choice, it would pick a chelator over an antioxidant. In the artificial-aging tests in Wholesale Supplies Plus's "Chemistry of DOS", 0.1% EDTA on its own delayed orange spots past 250 hours. It goes in dissolved in the reserved water.

EDTA is synthetic. For a fully plant-derived label, drop it and keep the ROE, which worked on its own in the same tests.

Classic Bells, Rancidity and DOS; WSP, The Chemistry of DOS

Rosemary oleoresin (ROE)

0.1% of oils

An antioxidant that slows oils going rancid. In the same WSP tests, 0.1% ROE alone was as effective as 0.1% EDTA, and "the combination of 0.1% EDTA and 0.1% ROE is even more effective." That pairing is exactly what this bar uses. The article notes ROE varies batch to batch and suggests buying one high in rosmarinic acid. Stir it into the warm oils before the lye goes in.

WSP, The Chemistry of DOS; Classic Bells, Rancidity and DOS

Lavender + cedarwood atlas essential oils

2% + 1% of oils

3% total. SoapCalc's guide puts essential oils at 19–25 g per kg of oils; Lovin Soap's author prefers 3% for cold process; the Nerdy Farm Wife chart lists 5% for lavender and 4% for cedarwood as maximums. Lavender carries the scent and cedarwood, a base note, holds it down. Each sits well under its listed maximum.

Get the IFRA certificate and SDS from your supplier and follow their limits. Buy fresh and store it cool and dark: Classic Bells notes that oxidized lavender oil can set off rancidity. For an unscented version, leave both out. Nothing else changes.

SoapCalc help; Lovin Soap (via search excerpt); Nerdy Farm Wife; Classic Bells

What we left out

Palm oil. Cocoa butter supplies the same palmitic and stearic acids, so the bar can be palm-free without being soft.
Avocado and other "luxury" oils. We modeled 6% avocado in place of olive and every quality number moved by less than one point. In soap, an oil is turned into its fatty-acid salts, and avocado's profile is close to olive's. An ingredient that changes nothing measurable shouldn't be on the label to look fancy.
Honey and milk. Both add sugars that can overheat or scorch, and they would end the vegan claim. Sugar does the lather job more predictably.
Sodium citrate. A first draft of this formula included it. In WSP's tests it was the chelator that did not work ("Of the two, only EDTA was effective"), and Classic Bells reports it helps only alongside BHT. Without BHT it adds nothing, so it's out.
BHT. Synthetic, and ROE does the antioxidant job in WSP's tests.
A higher superfat. 5% already covers SAP-table error with margin. More free oil means a softer bar and more oil to go rancid.

Method

Lye safety

  • Sodium hydroxide is corrosive. Wear goggles, gloves and long sleeves from weighing to cleanup.
  • Always add lye to water, never water to lye. Mix where fumes can vent, away from kids and pets.
  • Use stainless steel, or #2 (HDPE) or #5 (PP) plastic. Never aluminum: lye reacts with it.
  • Lye on skin: flush with plenty of running water.

    Cure and quality control

    Cure for six weeks

    Classic Bells sets four weeks as the minimum for cold-process soap: saponification finishes in a day or two, but water loss and crystal structure take weeks. This bar is 40% olive oil, so hold it to six weeks before selling.

    Weigh two bars when you cut them, then once a week. The bar is ready when weekly weight loss slows to a crawl.

    Expect 6–10% weight loss

    Put the cured weight on the label, not the cutting weight.

    Keep a batch log

    • Supplier and lot number for every oil, the lye and each essential oil
    • Actual weights, temperatures, trace time, date
    • Cure weights, and any spots or changes over the following months

    Package to breathe

    In Soapsmith's test, the untreated bar kept in muslin stayed almost spotless while the untreated bar left out on a shelf was covered in DOS. Use a cotton bag or paper band, not shrink wrap, and store bars cool and out of the sun.

    Selling it (United States)

    Under 21 CFR 701.20, FDA treats a product as "soap" only if it is mainly alkali salts of fatty acids, those salts do all the cleaning, and it's marketed only as soap. True soap is regulated by the CPSC. But FDA says a product meant to make the user smell nice is a cosmetic, and the CPSC says ingredients with cosmetic properties can make a product a cosmetic even with no claims. A bar scented with essential oils and named for its oatmeal should be labeled as a cosmetic. That's the safer reading, and a full ingredient list is something to be proud of anyway.

    What the label needs

    • Front panel: product identity ("Oat & Cedar Soap") and net weight, using the cured weight
    • Ingredients in descending order of predominance
    • Name and place of business. FDA says a P.O. box or website is not adequate.
    • Directions and warnings where needed

    MoCRA, briefly

    • Businesses averaging under $1,000,000 a year in U.S. cosmetics sales over the prior 3 years (inflation-adjusted) are exempt from facility registration, product listing and GMP rules.
    • Not exempt: reporting serious adverse events to FDA within 15 business days, and keeping records that substantiate the product's safety. The batch log helps here.
    • FDA still has to write the fragrance-allergen labeling rule. Watch for it.

    Fine to say

    • Palm-free, vegan
    • Made with shea and cocoa butter and colloidal oatmeal
    • Scented only with lavender and cedarwood essential oils
    • Cured six weeks; small batch

    Never say

    • Treats, heals or soothes eczema, acne, itching or any skin condition. FDA classes those as drug claims.
    • Antibacterial or kills germs (also a drug claim)
    • "Chemical-free" or "all natural". EDTA is synthetic and lye is a chemical.
    Draft ingredient line, in descending order by batch weight

    Olea Europaea (Olive) Fruit Oil, Water, Cocos Nucifera (Coconut) Oil, Butyrospermum Parkii (Shea) Butter, Theobroma Cacao (Cocoa) Seed Butter, Sodium Hydroxide, Ricinus Communis (Castor) Seed Oil, Lavandula Angustifolia (Lavender) Oil, Avena Sativa Kernel Flour, Sucrose, Cedrus Atlantica Bark Oil, Sodium Lactate, Tetrasodium EDTA, Rosmarinus Officinalis (Rosemary) Leaf Extract.

    Check every name against your supplier's spec sheet. ROE is usually sold diluted in a carrier oil, which also has to be listed. Some makers list the saponified forms instead ("Sodium Olivate, Sodium Cocoate…"). FDA's Cosmetics Labeling Guide doesn't address this either way, so pick one style and use it on every product.

    Before you sell a single bar

    This formula is built from published data and the math above, but it hasn't been made. The quality numbers are a model. Make the 1 lb test batch, cure it six weeks, and use it yourself and with a few testers for a month. Watch hardness, lather, any softening or spots. Then scale up. The selling notes summarize FDA and CPSC pages as of November 2026 and are not legal advice; confirm your product's status with FDA or a regulatory attorney before launch, and carry product liability insurance.

    Sources

    1. SoapCalc: Soap Making Oil Chart (SAP, iodine, INS, fatty acids)
    2. SoapCalc: Soap Qualities (suggested ranges)
    3. SoapCalc: How to Use (essential oil rates)
    4. Classic Bells: SoapCalc numbers (quality formulas)
    5. Classic Bells: Rancidity and DOS
    6. Classic Bells: Why soap needs to cure
    7. From Nature With Love: Saponification chart
    8. The Soapery: SAP values
    9. Soapsmith: DOS experiment (Dunn's additive rates)
    10. Wholesale Supplies Plus: The Chemistry of DOS
    11. Lovely Greens: Oatmeal Soap Recipe
    12. Bramble Berry: All About Butters
    13. Bramble Berry: All About Sodium Lactate
    14. Nurture: Sodium Lactate
    15. Bramble Berry: Colloidal Oatmeal
    16. Countryside: Salt, Sugar and Sodium Lactate in Soap
    17. Lovin Soap: Essential oil usage rates
    18. Nerdy Farm Wife: Essential oils for soapmaking
    19. Making Soap Naturally: Cure guide
    20. Wholesale Supplies Plus: Waiting for a cure
    21. FDA: Frequently Asked Questions on Soap
    22. CPSC: Soap business guidance
    23. FDA: Cosmetics Labeling Guide
    24. FDA: Small Businesses & Homemade Cosmetics
    25. FDA: MoCRA overview
    26. 21 U.S.C. § 364h: Small businesses